Skip to content

With an Eye to Rebuilding The Party, Recent Events Demonstrate Eaton is No Longer Relevant in GOP Politics

November 20, 2009

In our early months, Atlas was dedicated to reporting to you the problems with our party, how we got to where we are today, and suggestions on how to reform those problems. Then, our focus shifted as a sad state of political events and revelations unfolded during the course of the summer. It became clear that the leadership—failed Brooklyn GOP Chairman Craig “The Duke” Eaton—was either ignoring serious problems in our party or was the source of them.

Next came the controversial reelection of Chairman Eaton, which seemingly divided the Brooklyn GOP. For a month, Eaton dedicated himself to Bay Ridge events and ignored the rest of our borough, in spite of having a slate of borough-wide and non-Bay Ridge candidates running.

Finally, came the horrible and tragic elections of this month, which all but shattered the Brooklyn GOP. No GOP backed candidate—not even the Mayor—won in this borough.

After these events, I believe that the following conclusion is clear: Chairman Craig ”The Duke” Eaton is no longer relevant in GOP politics.

Take some post-election examples of failure and irrelevancy that stand out in particular.

In the aftermath of the elections, the party released no press release or statement—let alone any sign—that it was still breathing. Instead, the sad, lowly minions of Eaton’s empty promise agenda skulked off into the night, as many of you predicted, I’m sure—not to be heard from again. Some were still clinging to the corpse that was the Brooklyn GOP establishment. A few did so for the sake of sorrow. Others out of disbelief. But reports coming to us make it clear that most of Eaton’s closest acolytes have distanced themselves from him and the party.

Then, take the most recent healthcare rally that Eaton organized in the shadow of the Verrazano Bridge, within walking distance of his home. With a sparse crowd of mostly party figures, the “rally” was a total disaster. And why? Because Eaton limited the invite to his mailing list and did nothing to raise the attention of those that could have made his event better. We know that he has cut people off mailing lists. We know he has turned to his small, inner circle to desperately gain media attention where such attention has only been harmful and not good. He has gained so very little from all of his scheming and conniving, and he has accomplished nothing beneficial for you or me.

Well, at least he’s learned to advertise on Urban Elephants. Oh wait, “The Editors” did that for him…

It is clear that Craig Eaton does not know a thing about running a party. We here at Atlas have attempted to educate him and bring light to the problems in the party (and I assure you that I had to do some convincing before it became clear even to my fellow Atlas colleagues that Eaton was political caveman). But unfortunately, The Duke’s actions in the past few months have demonstrated that such an education is seemingly impossible.

He has Bay Ridge-wide priorities.

We here at Atlas have borough-wide priorities.

He is still clinging to the same “with us or without us” mentality that only threatens and never grows a party.

We believe in growing and expanding the party in all parts of the borough.

He believes in holding party rallies in Bay Ridge.

We believe in holding open and public rallies on issues that matter to all Brooklynites.


You see, the Duke does not know how to run a kingdom. He can barely draw a crowd in his own realm. It’s pathetic, sad, and outrageous, all at the same time.

In light of this, I pledge to you that I will not persist in elevating Mr. Eaton any higher than he already is. By speaking of him after the elections, we make him relevant, and I will not play a part in making such a failed Chairman anymore noticeable than he already is. To belabor the point would be a waste of time. He does not want to listen. His arrogance is so great, listening is beneath him.

We have exposed a great deal of party in fighting and mismanagement, and while there were those that previously doubted such grievous happenings in the Brooklyn GOP, the evidence speaks for itself.

Now, unfortunately, our monitoring of party finances and our emailers might prompt us to some action on the part of Chairman Eaton that might deserve reporting from time to time. I have no doubt that this will happen in the near future, given what we’ve heard in recent months.

In spite of this, I continue to invite you to vote until the end of this week on whether Chairman Eaton should resign. Why? Because our leaders, as sad and pathetic as they may be, must be reminded always that they are accountable. They must know that their actions do not come without consequence. So many have expressed that Eaton should step down. His failed leadership will hurt the party in 2010 and could make it even less relevant than it already is.

Your task, as reformist Republicans, it to do everything to prevent that.

In the next few days, I will offer some suggestions on how to circumvent the party leadership if you want to help change our borough in the coming year. Some of it will be common sense, but, amigos, that is just what is lacking in our party.

But we can do it.

We can rebuild our party.

We can strengthen our party.

We can grow our party.

We can do it together, with or without the party leadership.

Let’s get to work.

  1. Atlas Shrugger permalink
    November 20, 2009 12:24 pm

    Thanks to Stephanie at Urban Elephants for posting this! You probably beat Dagny to the punch!

  2. Young GOP Kid permalink
    November 20, 2009 12:36 pm

    I wholeheartedly agree that Eaton is totally irrelevant in NYC and state politics. Now, all he’s doing is hurting Marty Golden and any chance the party has at winning in 2010.

    We must circumvent him or our party will be lost over his ego.

    Forget that embarrassment Eaton. Plow ahead!

  3. Sexy Republicana permalink
    November 20, 2009 3:24 pm

    Irrelevant is right. I think a notice should be sent to the Democratic Party:

    RINO Leftovers: Craig Eaton – come and get ’em. LOL

    Let’s move on to relevant topics, like how to keep this madman from ruining what’s left of our beloved GOP!

  4. Gerry permalink
    December 18, 2009 11:10 pm

    This is fantastic! I just re-read it!


  1. BREAKING NEWS – Fiorello LaGuardia Club: “Bay Ridge GOP” Has Been “Demeaning” and “Detrimental” « Atlas Shrugs in Brooklyn
  2. DEVELOPING STORY – Taking Advice From Atlas, Brooklyn GOP Makes Moves To Renovate Derided Website « Atlas Shrugs in Brooklyn
  3. After Controversial Remarks, Gubernatorial Prospect Collins Meets Brooklyn GOP Leadership This Week « Atlas Shrugs in Brooklyn
  4. Final Results in Capano Race Are Fruits Borne From Alienating Tactics and Leadership Failures « Atlas Shrugs in Brooklyn
  5. LaGuardia Club Claims Own Holiday Party “A Huge Success” « Atlas Shrugs in Brooklyn
  6. Bay Ridge Cabal Bankrupting Party: Disclosure Reports Detail Bank Account Empty in Wake of Severe Mismanagement « Atlas Shrugs in Brooklyn
  7. Atlas Draws Huge Hits This Weekend, Poised To Break Record « Atlas Shrugs in Brooklyn
  8. With Eaton No Longer A Relevant Player in GOP Politics, Atlas Poll Indicates Resignation is His Best Course « Atlas Shrugs in Brooklyn
  9. Brooklyn GOP Website Undergoes Very Public Surgical Procedures, But Fundamental Flaws Remain « Atlas Shrugs in Brooklyn
  10. The Cathedral Club: The Tammany Hall of Bay Ridge? – An Introduction « Atlas Shrugs in Brooklyn
  11. BREAKING NEWS: In Stealthy Last Minute Release, The Bay Ridge Cabal Will Host Republican Candidates for Governor « Atlas Shrugs in Brooklyn
  12. UPDATE: Brooklyn GOP Fails To File Timely Disclosures Again, Violating Election Laws « Atlas Shrugs in Brooklyn
  13. As Queens GOP Endorses Lazio, Brooklyn GOP’s Lazio/Collins Meeting Falls Flat–Unfortunately For Brooklyn « Atlas Shrugs in Brooklyn
  14. BREAKING NEWS: A “Golden” Opportunity Squandered As Conservative Party Endorses Democrat In 44th City Council Race « Atlas Shrugs in Brooklyn
  15. Developing Story: Irrelevant Eaton “Hungry For Glory” As Democrat Kruger “Resolved” To Praise Him « Atlas Shrugs in Brooklyn
  17. BREAKING NEWS: 49th AD Leaders Issue Statement Regarding Brooklyn GOP’s Craigslist Embarrassment « Atlas Shrugs in Brooklyn

Comments are closed.

%d bloggers like this: